SEMI-AUTHORITARIAN, SEMI-FAILED STATE
Rashed Rahman
FINDINGS
- Pakistan presents a complex set of challenges at the national and international levels,
including the economic meltdown facing the country and the menace of jihadi extremism.
These two problems have now become inextricably linked, as the growing insurgency
is directly affecting the health of the economy.
- The emergence of vibrant private media, along with a nascent civil society, is one of
the most important positive developments in Pakistan in recent years. Nevertheless, the
media sector faces considerable obstacles related to the cultivation of a more mature class of media professionals, and the mounting economic crisis will place added pressure
on the industry. Moreover, illiberal voices, including extremists in the Swat region,
are threatening to smother open discussion and thwart the progress of democratic
development.
- The contradictory aims of the military and intelligence establishment with respect to
the Taliban and related groups appear to be dragging the country toward disaster. This
dogged adherence to a failed security policy, unchecked by elected civilian leaders, may
be the clearest illustration of the dangers of military rule.
- The military’s long dominance of the country’s domestic affairs has left an atrophied
civilian establishment that has been hard pressed to provide fresh leadership. Military
rule has not been the solution to Pakistan’s challenges. Efforts to deepen and improve the
quality of Pakistan’s democracy are therefore all the more urgent.
On June 4, 2009, a high level conference in Washington DC launched the "Undermining Democracy: 21st Century Authoritarians" study.